Yes, but... at the same time, she doesn't exactly agree with Meyer's statements if Meyer starts gushing about how wonderful Bella & Edward & Co. are. (I might be mixing up memories of other people who speculated that Edward didn't execute only true monsters with Mervin's commentary.) Which is what you're saying but...
It probably irks me only because, as Breaking Dawn is written, there's no evidence that Renesmee has the "adult mentality" that she keeps hammering the book on - so I'd think that would fall under the "lot of inconsistency" point. Yes, everything turns crazy if one insists on shoving the Adult Mentality point in there, but... isn't it simpler just to assume Meyer made shit up after the fact? I mean, I might be missing something - is there any indication in Breaking Dawn that Renesmee is an adult who plays the child, or is she just portrayed as an insanely precocious child (which is how I recall her)?
![[personal profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/user.png)
timeasmymeasure
no subject
Date: 2013-07-03 02:16 am (UTC)It probably irks me only because, as Breaking Dawn is written, there's no evidence that Renesmee has the "adult mentality" that she keeps hammering the book on - so I'd think that would fall under the "lot of inconsistency" point. Yes, everything turns crazy if one insists on shoving the Adult Mentality point in there, but... isn't it simpler just to assume Meyer made shit up after the fact? I mean, I might be missing something - is there any indication in Breaking Dawn that Renesmee is an adult who plays the child, or is she just portrayed as an insanely precocious child (which is how I recall her)?